Our top pick is Pearl Milling Company's Country Rich Homestyle Syrup, which has the perfect balance of a sweet and buttery flavor, and good consistency.īacked by our testing, here are the best pancake syrups.īest Overall: Pearl Milling Company Country Rich Homestyle Syrupīest Buttery Flavor: Log Cabin Original Syrupīest Sweet Flavor: Michele's Gourmet Maple Creme Syrupīest Thick Texture: Mrs. Our testing criteria included flavor, consistency, and overall value for the price. We drizzled each syrup over pancakes prepared during our boxed pancake mix test and on blank areas on the plate so we could try each pancake syrup individually while observing how each type of syrup interacted with the pancakes. This taste test was conducted over several weeks and involved six tasters.
We tested 11 kinds of pancake syrup, all available at grocery stores or online, to determine which was the very best. And when it oozes to other areas on your plate, pancake syrup gives savory breakfast meats like bacon and sausage just the right amount of contrast. Whether you prefer syrup soaking into your pancakes or pooling in the squares of your waffles, you can't deny that pancake syrup is an integral part of the breakfast experience.